Wrongful arrests could increase with city’s new gun detection tech, experts say • Brooklyn Paper


Photo by Paul Martinka

Misfire: Some legal experts say the city’s plan to bring ShotSpotter technology — which it began rolling out in Brooklyn in 2015 — to Fort Greene this summer will give cops a new reason to search and arrest innocent people who happen to be near the scene of detected shootings.

By Lauren Gill

Brooklyn Paper

Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook


Get our stories in your inbox, free.

Like Brooklyn Paper on Facebook.

It’s missing the target.

The city’s plan to install gun detection technology in Fort Greene this summer will give cops a new excuse to search and arrest people who aren’t doing anything wrong, legal experts fear.

“It’s going to generate a lot of arrests, a lot of collateral damage,” said Scott Cerbin, a Downtown criminal defense attorney. “It will create probable cause to approach and search people when there is none.”


The NYPD announced earlier this month that, by Labor Day, it will outfit the neighborhood with the so-called “ShotSpotter” system, which works by attaching audio sensors to roofs and light poles. The tech is supposed to recognize a shot once it is fired, and immediately send a recording of the sound back to the company’s California headquarters. Employees analyze the noise to assess whether it’s gunfire or something similar, such as fireworks, and issue an alert to police within 60 seconds if they think it’s actually a shot, according to ShotSpotter spokeswoman Lisa Hendrickson.

The system has about a five-percent false reporting rate, according to an AM New York report, and the New York Post reported it mistook several fireworks explosions as gunfire on the Fourth of July this year.

But it’s an important tool designed to alert authorities to incidents that otherwise might not be reported, according to NYPD spokesman Peter Donald, who noted 80 percent of shootings are not called in to 911.

The criminal defense attorney, however, said that although the system might detect gunfire, it does not identify a shooter, leaving those near the scene susceptible to arrest because authorities may target anyone who looks suspicious, even if he or she is innocent.

“It’s dangerous. As with any technology, it can be abused and misused, even if it’s not with malicious intent,” Cerbin said. “Police officers make mistakes, they arrest people when they think they have the right suspect and they don’t.”

Cops need probable cause to search someone, which can include a person’s consent or an emergency situation that threatens people’s safety, such as public gunfire. ShotSpotter could give police reason to frisk someone near the scene of a reported shooting, during which they could then find unrelated, non-violent contraband such as illegal drugs — evidence that judges should suppress in court, according to Cerbin, because it would have been obtained without probable cause. But that’s not always the case, he said, as many justices are in the pocket of the police department.

“In state court they’ll uphold whatever police bring to them,” he said. “They want to get reappointed, so there’s political pressure to not suppress evidence. Nine out of ten judges would not grant suppression.”

Judges have admitted ShotSpotter reports as evidence in court in New York state, according to Hendrickson.

Authorities have rolled out the technology in 14 police precincts across Brooklyn since 2015, concentrating it in areas where gun violence occurs “based on historical evidence,” according to police spokeswoman Detective Sophia Mason. Some of the neighborhoods those precincts cover include Crown Heights, East New York, Bedford-Stuyvesant, Canarsie, and Brownsville.

Cops chose to introduce the technology to Fort Greene based on the same analysis of past gun violence, but Mason did not disclose statistics supporting the need for it. The neighborhood is home to two public housing complexes, Ingersoll and Walt Whitman houses.

There have been five shooting incidents in the 88th Precinct, which covers the nabe, so far this year, up from three last year, according to city data.

Another expert said cops should implement the technology throughout the city so it isn’t concentrated in areas with public housing or high minority populations.

“This is something that’s going to lean towards minority areas and again, there will be more minorities being arrested,” said Brooklyn-based criminal defense attorney Wilson LaFaurie. “Police pick a type and say if you look for that particular type, that’s most likely going to be the kind of person who is committing a crime — baggy jeans, hoodie, young.”

The lawyer pointed out the system could be helpful in locating gunfire, because people usually don’t report it to 911 since they don’t know where it occurs, but said he doesn’t support its use if it gives cops more leeway to convict innocent people.

“It’s going to be pretty interesting how they utilize this and if they use it as probable cause, I’m dead against it,” he said.

But a rep for Mayor DeBlasio said the city is not worried about the technology putting people who haven’t done anything wrong at risk.

“ShotSpotter is a highly effective crime-fighting tool that helps law enforcement respond to shootings quicker and investigate them more precisely than ever before,” said Austin Finan. “That means targeting and arresting violent criminals, not individuals who might be in the wrong place at the wrong time.”

When asked how police differentiate between violent criminals and those in the wrong place at the wrong time, he passed the question onto the police spokesman, who said the only Brooklynites that ShotSpotter poses a threat to are those intimidated by guns, not people who may be wrongfully incriminated.

“The only people put at risk are those struck by gunfire or terrorized by violence on their block,” he said.

Reach reporter Lauren Gill at lgill@cnglocal.com or by calling (718) 260–2511. Follow her on Twitter @laurenk_gill

Posted 12:00 am, August 17, 2017

Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook


Get our stories in your inbox, free.

Like Brooklyn Paper on Facebook.